273 South Cayuga Road

About this Property

For generations, this building served as both a place of worship and a gathering place for the community before being thoughtfully transformed into an extraordinary one-of-a-kind residence where history and modern living exist in perfect harmony. During an extensive 2019 restoration, the original structure was taken back to its brick shell and completely reimagined, preserving the architectural character while creating a home designed for today's lifestyle. Each morning, the rising sun shines through the original stained-glass window, casting ever-changing colours across the soaring 22-foot great room and creating a welcome unlike any other. The open-concept main living space is complemented by a loft overlooking the great room, while the library offers a cozy reading nook/loft and access to a new deck completed in 2026—an inviting place to relax beneath the canopy of mature trees. Privately tucked away on the second level, the primary suite feels like its own retreat, featuring a walk-through closet, a spa-inspired ensuite with a large walk-in shower, soaker tub beneath a skylight, and a private balcony completed in 2026 where you can unwind surrounded by nature. Two additional bedrooms with impressive 12-foot ceilings provide generous space for family or guests. The bright lower level features its own separate entrance, high ceilings and an abundance of natural light, offering endless possibilities for the next owner to create a space that reflects their own lifestyle. Outside, the detached 30' x 25' heated and air-conditioned garage/shop is equally impressive, complete with its own electrical panel and EV charging connection. Set on a peaceful country property backing onto farmland, this is far more than a beautifully restored home—it's a rare opportunity to become the next steward of a landmark that has brought people together for generations.

Listing Details

MLS #

40867671

Board

ITSO

Market

ontario

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Style

Gothic Revival

Year Built

1890

Garage Spaces

2

Parking Spaces

6

Fireplaces

1

Basement

Separate Entrance, Full, Unfinished, Sump Pump

Heating

Forced Air, Natural Gas

Cooling

Central Air

Lot Size

142.19 × 90.96 ft

Annual Taxes

$3,056/yr

Listed By

Pay It Forward Realty

Presented By

REMAX Hallmark®

Listed On

September 30, 2026

Days on Market

4

Features & Extras